Who Do You Believe? (2022–present)

TV ShowOn airABCCrime, Documentary1 season, 8 episodes
Who Do You Believe? poster

Plot

Simultaneous storytelling takes viewers through compelling true-crime cases from dual perspectives. The audience steps into the shoes of two contrasting narratives to hear the recounts directly from the victims and criminals with never-before-revealed details.

Episodes by season

Season018Episodes2022Aired—Season avg
  1. S01E01Who Do You Believe? S01E01Overwhelming CharityMay 3, 2022—Secrets from the past are revealed as newly married Mark and Charity navigate their rocky relationship.
  2. S01E02Who Do You Believe? S01E02Protector vs. PredatorMay 10, 2022—Actress Nichelle Nichols is caught between her son and her new manager in a vicious and public battle for conservatorship.
  3. S01E03Who Do You Believe? S01E03What the Sisters Saw - Part 1May 17, 2022—The life of a struggling mother of two teenage girls is shattered by a late-night shotgun blast that leaves one of them dead and the other d
  4. S01E04Who Do You Believe? S01E04What The Sisters Saw - Part 2May 31, 2022—The riveting battle between Celeste Beard and her twin teenage daughters continues to unfold in part two of this unbelievable true-crime sto
  5. S01E05Who Do You Believe? S01E05Slayed While SleepingJune 7, 2022—
  6. S01E06Who Do You Believe? S01E06Legacy & LiesJune 14, 2022—
  7. S01E07Who Do You Believe? S01E07Kill Thy NeighborJuly 5, 2022—
  8. S01E08Who Do You Believe? S01E08Dad's Deadly DeedsJuly 12, 2022—

Season 1 ranked & reviewed

Cast

Mia Bankston
Mia BankstonNarrator (voice)

Photos

View all
1 / 7

Who Do You Believe?

Poster · 1 of 7

Shows like Who Do You Believe? all similar shows

The closest matches on shared genres, ranked by match strength and popularity.

  1. 01Documentary·CrimeTrust Me: The False Prophet2026In this true-crime documentary, a cult expert and filmmaker infiltrate a polygamist sect to expose a self-proclaimed prophet and bring him to justice.Compare
  2. 02Crime·DocumentaryDateline1992Dateline NBC, or simply Dateline, is a weekly American television newsmagazine series.6.5Compare
  3. 03Documentary·CrimeHomicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda2011A non-fiction investigative series of murder cases told through the personal experience of retired detective, Lieutenant Joe Kenda.Compare
  4. 04Crime·DocumentaryInside the World's Toughest Prisons2016Crime journalist Raphael Rowe goes behind the bars of some of the world’s most notorious and toughest prisons.7.1Compare
  5. 05Documentary·CrimeI AM A KILLER2018Death row inmates convicted of capital murder give a firsthand account of their crimes in this documentary series.6.8Compare
  6. 06Documentary·CrimeFred and Rose West: A British Horror Story2025Recently discovered police recordings and first-person accounts tell the story of Fred and Rose West, two of the UK's most prolific murderers.Compare

Head-to-head pick any opponent

Stack Who Do You Believe?'s full episode-rating history against a rival, on one chart.

Who Do You Believe? vs Trust Me: The False ProphetFull episode chartWho Do You Believe? vs DatelineFull episode chartWho Do You Believe? vs Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe KendaFull episode chart

Keep exploring top shows

ShortcutThe essential episodes

Short on time? The pilot-to-finale shortcut, only the episodes that matter.

MatchupCompare with another show

Two shows' episode ratings on one chart — settle it.

NetworkBest ABC shows

More from the same network, ranked by rating.

GenreBest crime shows & films

The top of the crime pile, across both mediums.

GenreBest documentary shows & films

The top of the documentary pile, across both mediums.