Murder Most Puzzling poster
Seen it?

Murder Most Puzzling

TV·2025·5·Drama, Crime, Mystery·2h·7.4

Streaming on (US) PBS Masterpiece Amazon ChannelThirteenWETA+See all

When a strange murder takes place in the sleepy market town of Bakerbury. The local police are baffled by a crossword puzzle left on the body.

With their case going nowhere, they turn reluctantly to Cora Felton, a recent arrival in Bakerbury; whose fame as the eponymous Puzzle Lady suggests she can help DCI Hooper and the Bakerbury police solve its first murder case. But the eccentric Cora isn't who she claims to be, and as she throws herself into a murder case that has the town's residents baffled, she starts to gather allies and enemies in equal measure.

Cast

Phyllis LoganPhyllis LoganCora FeltonCharlotte HopeCharlotte HopeSherry CarterAlistair BrammerAlistair BrammerAnton GrantNick DananNick DananDS Sam BrodyAdam BestAdam BestDCI Derek HooperAshionye Michelle RaccahAshionye Michelle RaccahBabs Dufresne

Shows like Murder Most Puzzling all similar shows

The closest matches on shared genres, ranked by match strength and popularity.

  1. 01Drama·Crime·MysteryGrantchester2014–present·PBS PassportStreaming on NetflixEavesdropping on the life of Sidney Chambers, a charismatic, charming, crime-fighting clergyman, and his partner in crime Police Inspector Geordie Keating, became a highlight for the audience who revelled in their on…7.7Compare
  2. 02Drama·Crime·MysteryHigh Potential2024–present·ABCStreaming on HuluHigh Potential follows Morgan, a single mom with an exceptional mind, whose unconventional knack for solving crimes leads to an unusual and unstoppable partnership with a by-the-book seasoned detective.7.4Compare
  3. 03Drama·Crime·MysteryCastle2009–2016·ABCStreaming on Amazon Prime VideoCastle follows Rick Castle who is one of the world's most successful crime authors.8.2Compare
  4. 04Drama·Crime·MysteryThe Mentalist2008–2015·CBSStreaming on HuluPatrick Jane, an independent consultant with the California Bureau of Investigation (CBI), has a remarkable track record for solving serious crimes by using his razor sharp skills of observation.8.2Compare
  5. 05Drama·Crime·MysteryElementary2012–2019·CBSStreaming on Amazon Prime VideoElementary is a modern-day take on the classic Sherlock Holmes story about a crime-solving duo that cracks the NYPD's most impossible cases.8.3Compare
  6. 06Drama·Crime·MysteryDexter2006–2013·Paramount+ with ShowtimeStreaming on fuboTVHe's smart, he's good looking, and he's got a great sense of humor.8.4Compare

Head-to-head pick any opponent

Stack Murder Most Puzzling's full episode-rating history against a rival, on one chart.

Murder Most Puzzling vs GrantchesterFull episode chartMurder Most Puzzling vs High PotentialFull episode chartMurder Most Puzzling vs CastleFull episode chart

Keep exploring top shows

ShortcutThe essential episodes

Short on time? The pilot-to-finale shortcut, only the episodes that matter.

MatchupCompare with another show

Two shows' episode ratings on one chart — settle it.

NetworkBest 5 shows

More from the same network, ranked by rating.

GenreBest drama shows & films

The top of the drama pile, across both mediums.

GenreBest crime shows & films

The top of the crime pile, across both mediums.