Killer Cakes (2024–2024)

Plot

Host Matthew Lillard welcomes four teams of killer cake artists to an abandoned warehouse, where they will compete for $20,000 and the Golden Knife trophy. They will work with some of the best horror special effects artists in Hollywood to bring their cakes to life and scare the hell out of the show’s expert judges—Scream Queen Danielle Harris and food artist and Halloween aficionado Nikk Alcaraz.

Email me if Killer Cakes returns or gets revived

Highest-rated episodes all ranked

  1. 01Killer Cakes S01E02Possessed PastryS01E02 · 7.0In the second challenge of this Halloween special, Host Matthew Lillard challenges the three surviving teams of cake artists to create a possessed cake with a thrilling and devilishly delicious surprise for the judges. They will have just six hours to bake and create this cake with the help of Hollywood special effects artists. At stake: the Golden Knife trophy, $20,000—and their lives!
  2. 02Killer Cakes S01E01The Killer Never DiesS01E01 · 6.0Host Matthew Lillard welcomes four teams of cake artists to an abandoned and terrifying warehouse. They will have just six hours to bake and create a cake with the help of Hollywood special effects artists that depicts a killer that refuses to die. And, it must taste delicious. At stake: the Golden Knife trophy, $20,000 and salvation!

Episodes by season

Season012Episodes2024Aired 6.5Season avg
  1. S01E01Killer Cakes S01E01The Killer Never DiesOctober 8, 2024 6.0Host Matthew Lillard welcomes four teams of cake artists to an abandoned and terrifying warehouse. They will have just six hours to bake and
  2. S01E02Killer Cakes S01E02Possessed PastryOctober 8, 2024 7.0In the second challenge of this Halloween special, Host Matthew Lillard challenges the three surviving teams of cake artists to create a pos

Season 1 ranked & reviewed

Cast

Shows like Killer Cakes all similar shows

The closest matches on shared genres, ranked by match strength and popularity.

  1. 01RealityIs It Cake?2022Skilled cake artists create mouthwatering replicas of handbags, sewing machines and more in a mind-bending baking contest inspired by a popular meme.6.9Compare
  2. 02RealityHarry Potter: Wizards of Baking2024Pairs of professional bakers compete to create spellbinding edible showpieces on the actual sets where the Harry Potter films were made.Compare
  3. 03RealityThe Great British Bake Off2017Britain's best amateur bakers compete in the iconic white tent - all united in their aim to prove their baking skills and impress judges Paul Hollywood and Prue Leith.Compare
  4. 04RealityNailed It!2018Home bakers with a terrible track record take a crack at re-creating edible masterpieces for a $10,000 prize.7.1Compare
  5. 05RealityThe Great British Bake Off2010This British television baking competition selects from amongst its competitors the best amateur baker.7.5Compare
  6. 06RealityCutthroat Kitchen2013Just how far is a chef willing to go to win a cooking competition?Compare

Head-to-head pick any opponent

Stack Killer Cakes's full episode-rating history against a rival, on one chart.

Keep exploring top shows