All Her Fault poster
Seen it?

All Her Fault

TV·2025–2025·Peacock·Drama, Thriller, Mystery·52m·7.2·Created by Megan Gallagher

Streaming on (US) Peacock PremiumPeacock Premium PlusSee all

Set in Chicago, Marissa Irvine arrives at 14 Arthur Avenue, expecting to pick up her young son Milo from his first playdate with a boy at his new school. But the woman who answers the door isn't a mother she recognizes. She isn't the nanny. She doesn't have Milo. And so begins every parent's worst nightmare. 

Cast

Sarah SnookSarah SnookMarissa IrvineJake LacyJake LacyPeter IrvineSophia LillisSophia LillisCarrie FinchMichael PeñaMichael PeñaDetective AlcarasDakota FanningDakota FanningJenny KaminskiAbby ElliottAbby ElliottLia IrvineJay EllisJay EllisColin DobbsDuke McCloudDuke McCloudMilo Irvine

Shows like All Her Fault all similar shows

The closest matches on shared genres, ranked by match strength and popularity.

  1. 01Drama·Thriller·MysteryTaboo2017–present·BBC OneStreaming on fuboTV1814: James Keziah Delaney returns to London from Africa and is encircled by conspiracy, murder and betrayal.8.3Compare
  2. 02Drama·Thriller·MysteryRevenge2011–2015·ABCStreaming on HuluThis is not a story about forgiveness; Revenge is a show about retribution.7.8Compare
  3. 03Drama·Thriller·MysteryManifest2018–2023Streaming on NetflixWhen Montego Air Flight 828 landed safely after a turbulent but routine flight, the crew and passengers were relieved.7.0Compare
  4. 04Drama·Thriller·MysteryVigil2021–present·BBC iPlayerAlso on Peacock PremiumThe deeper you go, the darker it gets. Military investigator DCI Silva fights to uncover conspiracies of silence - but who can she trust?7.6Compare
  5. 05Drama·Thriller·MysteryThe Tourist2022–2024·BBC iPlayerStreaming on NetflixIn the glowing red heart of the Australian outback, a British man is pursued by a vast tank truck trying to drive him off the road.7.0Compare
  6. 06Drama·Thriller·MysterySherlock & Daughter2025·The CWStreaming on HBO Max Amazon ChannelThe mystery thriller Sherlock & Daughter puts Sherlock Holmes out of his comfort zone, mysteriously unable to investigate a sinister case without risking the lives of his closest friends.6.8Compare

Head-to-head pick any opponent

Stack All Her Fault's full episode-rating history against a rival, on one chart.

All Her Fault vs TabooFull episode chartAll Her Fault vs RevengeFull episode chartAll Her Fault vs ManifestFull episode chart

Keep exploring top shows

ShortcutThe essential episodes

Short on time? The pilot-to-finale shortcut, only the episodes that matter.

MatchupCompare with another show

Two shows' episode ratings on one chart — settle it.

NetworkBest Peacock shows

More from the same network, ranked by rating.

GenreBest drama shows & films

The top of the drama pile, across both mediums.

GenreBest thriller shows & films

The top of the thriller pile, across both mediums.