Hidden gems

Underrated supernatural shows

Great supernatural series that flew under the radar — high ratings, smaller audience, ranked so the best-kept secrets come first.

Surprise me with oneBest supernatural of 2026

Genre
Gravity Falls8.8
Gravity Falls
Gortimer Gibbon's Life on Normal Street8.0
Gortimer Gibbon's Life on Normal Street
In Search of.....8.0
In Search of.....
Julie and the Phantoms8.0
Julie and the Phantoms
Ghost Adventures: House Calls8.0
Ghost Adventures: House Calls
Inside No. 98.0
Inside No. 9
The Exorcist8.0
The Exorcist
Khemjira7.9
Khemjira
Joan of Arcadia7.8
Joan of Arcadia
Ghost Adventures: Serial Killer Spirits7.8
Ghost Adventures: Serial Killer Spirits
Wolf Lake7.8
Wolf Lake
Help! My House is Haunted7.8
Help! My House is Haunted
Chainsaw Man7.8
Chainsaw Man
The Proof Is Out There: Unexplained Edition7.8
The Proof Is Out There: Unexplained Edition
Reaper7.8
Reaper

Underrated shows by genre

Good to know

What makes a TV show underrated?

These are series rated 7.8 or higher by viewers but parked well outside the most-watched tier — genuinely good supernatural shows that never got the audience they deserved.

Are these supernatural shows actually worth watching?

Every title here clears a 7.8+ rating, so the score is real — just under the radar. Top of the list: Gravity Falls, Gortimer Gibbon's Life on Normal Street, In Search of......

Where can I stream these hidden gems?

Every series links to its page with live streaming availability for your country.

Keep exploring