P.I. Undercover: New York

Shows like What We Do in the Shadows

The closest matches on shared genres, ranked by match strength and popularity.

1. 01Comedy·Horror·SupernaturalGoosebumps2023–2025·Disney+Goosebumps follows a group of five high schoolers who unleash supernatural forces upon their town and must all work together – thanks to and in spite of their friendships, rivalries, and pasts with each other – in order…6.6
2. 02Comedy·Horror·SupernaturalLittle Demon2022–2022·FXX13 years after being impregnated by the Devil, a reluctant mother and her Antichrist daughter attempt to live an ordinary life in Delaware, but are constantly thwarted by monstrous forces, including Satan, who yearns…4.8
3. 03Comedy·Supernatural·MysteryWednesday2022–presentSmart, sarcastic and a little dead inside, Wednesday Addams investigates a murder spree while making new friends — and foes — at Nevermore Academy.7.9
4. 04Horror·SupernaturalAnne Rice's Interview with the Vampire2022–2024·AMC+Based on Anne Rice's iconic and bestselling novel, Anne Rice's Interview with the Vampire follows Louis de Pointe, Lestat de Lioncourt and Claudia's epic story of love, blood and the perils of immortality, as told to…6.6
5. 05Comedy·HorrorWidow's Bay2026–presentWidow's Bay is about a mysteriously cursed New England island and its superstitious citizens, led by a mayor who refuses to believe their warnings.7.6
6. 06Horror·Supernatural·ThrillerPenny Dreadful2014–2016·Paramount+ with ShowtimeSome of literature's most terrifying characters, including Dr.8.2

Keep going