The Sisters Mills

Guest stars

Alana Cavanaughas Saffron Paynter

Dustin Lewisas Paul Revere

Makabe Ganeyas Betsy's Nephew

Julia Armitageas Alice

Brittany Wilkersonas Gregory's Mom

Cynthia Evansas Max's Wife

Elyse DuFouras Babysitter / Lisa

Katie Cofieldas Teacher

BBrooklyn Garmonas Tessa Paynter

Lawton Denisas Gregory Gonda

JJoe Hardy Jr.as Max Paynter

SSamantha Annas Abyzou

MMyles Lawsinas Child

Sara Rudesealas Betsy's Nurse

Crew

Guillermo NavarroDirector

Heather RegnierWriter

Shows like Sleepy Hollow

The closest matches on shared genres, ranked by match strength and popularity.

1. 01Drama·Mystery·SupernaturalOuter Range2022–2024Outer Range centers on Royal Abbott, a rancher fighting for his land and family, who discovers an unfathomable phenomenon at the edge of Wyoming's wilderness, in the form of a dark void.7.1
2. 02Drama·Mystery·SupernaturalSchool Spirits2023–present·Paramount+When Maddie finds herself trapped in afterlife limbo at her high school, she decides to investigate her own mysterious disappearance.7.3
3. 03Drama·Mystery·SupernaturalSanctuary: A Witch's Tale2024·AMC+Based on the novel by V.V. James, Sanctuary: A Witch's Tale is set in a contemporary world where witchcraft is real.6.1
4. 04Drama·Mystery·SupernaturalPushing Daisies2007–2009·ABCAs a young boy Ned discovers that he can return the dead briefly back to life with just one touch.8.1
5. 05Drama·Mystery·SupernaturalThe Messengers2015–2015·The CWAn apocalyptic event on Earth gives five strangers angelic powers, and it also brings a mysterious dark figure to the planet.6.7
6. 06Drama·Mystery·SupernaturalSurrealEstate2021–2025·SyfySurrealEstate revolves around real estate agent Luke Roman and an elite team of specialists who handle the cases that no one else can: haunted and possessed houses that literally scare would-be buyers away.7.1

Keep going