One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill· Season 4 · Episode 5

I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness

S04E05·October 25, 2006·1h·The CW

When Lucas discovers that Derek's interest in Peyton is more than brotherly, Derek becomes menacing. Haley feels Nathan slipping away when he receives a scholarship offer to attend Duke University. As rumors of Brooke's pregnancy spread, Rachel uses the Internet to set Brooke up on a blind date with an older guy. At Nathan's request, Deb tries to kick her pill addiction.

Streaming on (US) HuluHBO Max Amazon ChannelYouTube TVSee all

Crew

Stuart GillardStuart GillardDirector
Mark SchwahnMark SchwahnWriter

Shows like One Tree Hill

The closest matches on shared genres, ranked by match strength and popularity.

  1. 01Drama·Action·Science-FictionArrow2012–2020Same network — The CWAfter a violent shipwreck, billionaire playboy Oliver Queen was missing and presumed dead for five years before being discovered alive on a remote island in the Pacific.7.4
  2. 02Drama·Crime·ThrillerTrue Detective2014–presentAlso on HBO MaxTouch darkness and darkness touches you back.8.1
  3. 03Drama·Action·Science-FictionThe Flash2014–2023Same network — The CW·Streaming on Netflix7.5
  4. 04Drama·Action·SupernaturalSupernatural2005–2020Same network — The CW·Streaming on Amazon Prime Video8.3
  5. 05Drama·Horror·ThrillerAmerican Horror Story2011–present·FXStreaming on Amazon Prime VideoAmerican Horror Story is an horror television anthology series.7.5
  6. 06Drama·Comedy·CrimeFargo2014·FXAlso on HuluFargo is a seasonal anthology crime drama with some dark comical elements, inspired by the film Fargo written by the Coen brothers.8.6

Keep going

SeasonSeason 4 ranked & reviewed

Every episode in airing order with ratings and dates.

StreamWhere to watch One Tree Hill

Every streaming service and region, checked around the clock.

MatchupShows like One Tree Hill

The closest matches, ranked by overlap and rating.