Fair rating?Every Year After· Season 1 · Episode 3
Playing with Fire
Delilah tells Jordie her secret, Chantal enlists Charlie's help with a crisis, and Percy and Sam spend more time together-which quickly feels like playing with fire. It's almost like high school all over again... like that summer of the power outage and the bonfire party, where hormones were raging and emotions were high.
Streaming on (US) 
See all
#3In Season 1of 8 rated episodes
#3All-timeof 8 rated episodes
+0.1vs season avgSeason 1 averages 6.4
2026First airedJune 10, 2026
Guest stars
Juliette Hawkas Young Percy Fraser
Blue Clarkeas Young Sam Florek
Gaalen Engenas Stuart DonnellyArielle Cartwrightas Charlie's Girlfriend
Leighton Lamas Local Girl
Simon Auclairas Cute BoyCrew
Jeff W. ByrdDirector
John StephensTeleplayShows like Every Year After
The closest matches on shared genres, ranked by match strength and popularity.
- 01Romance·Adventure·Science-FictionOutlander2014–2026·STARZ
Outlander follows the story of Claire Randall, a married combat nurse from 1945 who is mysteriously swept back in time to 1743, where she is immediately thrown into an unknown world where her life is threatened. - 02Romance·Drama·MedicalGrey's Anatomy2005–present·ABCThe doctors of Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital deal with life-or-death consequences on a daily basis -- it's in one another that they find comfort, friendship and, at times, more than friendship.
- 03Romance·Drama·SupernaturalTrue Blood2008–2014·HBO
True Blood is a horror/drama based on a series of novels called The Southern American Vampires Mysteries. - 04Romance·Drama·SupernaturalThe Originals2013–2018·The CWThe Originals is a spin-off show from the supernatural drama The Vampire Diaries.
- 05Romance·Drama·SupernaturalThe Vampire Diaries2009–2017·The CW
The Vampire Diaries is a supernatural drama/romance based around Elena Gilbert who falls in love with a 163 year old vampire.Based on a novel series by L.J. - 06Romance·Drama·HistoryReign2013–2017·The CWHidden between the lines of the history books is the story of Mary Stuart, the young woman the world would come to know as Mary, Queen of Scots.
