Fair rating?Ick, A Bod
Elsbeth must separate trick from treat in Sleepy Hollow when a rivalry reaches a ghoulish climax on Halloween night after a suburban housewife butts heads with a new neighbor; Capt. Wagner makes a frightening discovery about his daughter.
Streaming on (US) 
See all
#12In Season 3of 20 rated episodes
#39All-timeof 50 rated episodes
−0.1vs season avgSeason 3 averages 7.4
2025First airedOctober 30, 2025
Guest stars
Molly Priceas Detective Jackie Donnelly
Sullivan Jonesas Dr. Cameron Clayden
Braeden De La Garzaas Detective Rivers
Brittany Ingeas Julia Payne Wagner
Annaleigh Ashfordas Sharon Norman
Kate Jennings Grantas Beryl Nix
Ashley Austin Morrisas AmyJeremy Parrottas Xander Drake
Theis Weckesseras Lucas Norman
James P. Reesas Chop
Grant Harrisonas Sawyer DiggsTiffany Rachelle Stewartas Tara
Olivia Dapondeas Avery NormanCrew
Lionel ColemanDirector
Erica LarsonWriter