Fair rating?Black as Cole
After pondering a marriage proposal from Cole, Phoebe is forced to face a blast from his demonic past when the widow of one of his past victims hunts him down, looking for vengeance. As a result, they're forced to face an old protégé of Belthazor's who likes to kill witches with the same athame Cole used to use. However, when Paige learns of this, she has an instant mistrust of Cole and tries to convince her sisters to vanquish him. Meanwhile, Paige helps Leo and Piper find out whether they're ready to have kids.
Streaming on (US) ![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
See all
#3In Season 4of 22 rated episodes
#5All-timeof 178 rated episodes
+0.3vs season avgSeason 4 averages 8.4
2001First airedNovember 15, 2001
Guest stars
Bonnie Rootas Susan Coleman
Vincent Angellas Human SykesHeather Dawnas Emma
Michael Bailey Smithas BelthazorAaron Brumfieldas Demon Sykes
Kaycee Shankas Kari
Matthew Herronas Annoying Man
Sara Lynn Moneymakeras Marika
Crew
Les LandauDirector
Brad KernTeleplay
Nell ScovellTeleplayAbbey CampbellStory